A Little Life – Hanya Yanagihara

Are you happy? he once asked Jude (they must have been drunk).

I don’t think happiness is for me, Jude had said at last, as if Willem had been offering him a dish he didn’t want to eat.

A Little Life starts as the story of four friends living in New York City. Jude, Willem, JB and Malcolm met at college and have remained friends into their late twenties. Jude and Willem are renting an apartment together. Malcolm’s living at home and JB’s living in a ‘massive, filthy loft in Little Italy’.

JB is an artist but is working as a receptionist at an art magazine in Soho trying to convince them to feature him. Early on in the novel he begins to take photographs of their group, photographs that will eventually make him very successful although that success will come at a price. Willem is an actor, waiting tables at the beginning of the novel but, like JB, he will go on to become incredibly successful. Malcolm works for Ratstar Architects, a position he only took to please his parents. He wants to create buildings and makes small, detailed models. He will also go on to be incredibly successful. Jude is an assistant prosecutor in the criminal division of the U.S. Attorney’s Office. Guess what? He will also go on to be incredibly successful. However, Jude becomes the focus of the novel as his background and the consequences of it are far more complex than those of the other characters.

They were talking but Jude’s eyes were closed, and Willem knew – from the constant, hummingbird-flutter of his eyelids and the way his hand was curled into a fist so tight that Willem could see the ocean-green threads of his veins jumping under the back of his hand – that he was in pain. He knew from how rigid Jude was holding his legs, which were resting atop a box of books, that the pain was severe, and he knew too that there was nothing he could do for him. If he said, “Jude, let me get you some aspirin,” Jude would say, “I’m fine, Willem, I don’t need anything,” and if he said, “Jude, why don’t you lie down,” Jude would say, “Willem. I’m fine. Stop worrying.” So finally, he did what they had all learned over the years to do when Jude’s legs were hurting him, which was to make some excuse, get up, and leave the room, so Jude could lie perfectly still and wait for the pain to pass without having to make conversation or expend energy pretending that everything was fine and that he was just tired, or had cramp, or whatever feeble explanation he was able to invent.

 Jude has problems with his legs that stem from a car incident. The nature of this incident isn’t related until late on in the book but it is revealed early in the novel that Jude was abandoned by some bins as a baby and discovered by monks who took him in and brought him up whilst systematically abusing him. Jude’s friends know little about his upbringing, only Andy, his doctor, knows the details of his childhood. Andy treats Jude for the long-term injuries inflicted by the abuse and for Jude’s self-harming which is frequent and often very severe.

As well as his close friends, Jude develops a strong relationship with his university tutor, Harold Stein. Jude begins working for Harold as a research assistant. Eventually he’s invited for dinner and then, along with Willem, JB and Malcolm, to their house on Cape Cod. Over the years, visits become a ritual and finally, Harold and his wife, Julia, adopt Jude as their adult son.

A Little Life is a harrowing read. The abuse inflicted upon Jude and the abuse he inflicts upon himself is brutal and relentless. The detail Yanagihara writes in gives the novel an overwhelming, claustrophobic feel. As a reader, you are entombed in Jude’s world, watching and feeling his suffering but unable to do anything about it. You are placed in the same position as his friends and it’s a heart-breaking position to be in.

But it’s the portrayal of these friendships that are key to the novel’s success: Yanagihara details the shifts as the men get older and become successful in each of their fields. She shows what happens as romantic relationships form and priorities change. The friendships revolve around Jude, the absence of knowledge about his childhood creating a magnetic effect that draws them to him and keep them orbiting, wondering at the contents of the void and trying to support him through the damage inflicted upon him.

There’s been a lot of discussion about this novel on Twitter recently and it’s interesting to see the range of reactions. A Little Life is clearly not for everyone. It is harrowing, it is intense, it is an experience. It details an unusual life. What I think is particularly impressive is that Yanagihara has taken four men of different ethnicities and different sexualities, one of whom is disabled and written about their lives as though they are, well, people. They are not defined by their ethnicity or sexuality and this feels like a break through.

My problem with the novel is that once again, a brilliant female novelist is being lauded for a brilliant book written about men (see also Hilary Mantel and A.M. Homes). I have no doubt that if A Little Life had a cast of four female characters reviews would have made comparisons to Sex and the City and heavyweight prize panels wouldn’t have been anywhere near as keen to shortlist it. It’s been interesting on a similar note to see people criticize Yanagihara for having completed the first draft of this 720 page book in 18 months. Last year when Kashuo Ishiguro revealed that he drafted the 270 page, Booker Prize winning, The Remains of the Day in three weeks, he was a genius and everyone else should quit trying.

Despite my concern, there’s no doubt that A Little Life is one of the best books I’ve ever read. It’s rare for me to become so absorbed in a novel that I feel as though I’ve lived it. I couldn’t stop thinking about it for weeks after finishing it and I couldn’t read anything else for days after either, there was no space left in my brain.

A Little Life moves the idea of what the Great American Novel is on to something a little more representative of actual people. Yes, Jude, Willem, JB and Malcolm are all living the American Dream but – at last – we have moved beyond the realm of the white middle class. I look forward to seeing Hanya Yanagihara celebrated on the cover of Time magazine.

Thanks to Picador for the review copy.

56 thoughts on “A Little Life – Hanya Yanagihara

  1. Great review & frank observations that should be aired more often Naomi… I’ve got this on kindle but feel like I will have to choose my time to read it very carefully. Have you read The People in the Trees?

    • Thanks, Poppy. Yes, it’s not one to read when you’re feeling a bit fragile, nor at a moment when you can’t dedicate fairly long stretches of time to it – not because the prose is dense and difficult, it isn’t, but because it’s overwhelming and utterly absorbing. I haven’t read The People in the Trees but I bought it before I’d finished A Little Life as I want to see whether there’s any hint that she’d produce a work this significant afterwards.

  2. Great review & frank observations that should be aired more often Naomi… I’ve got this on kindle but feel like I will have to choose my time to read it very carefully. Have you read The People in the Trees?

    • Thanks, Poppy. Yes, it’s not one to read when you’re feeling a bit fragile, nor at a moment when you can’t dedicate fairly long stretches of time to it – not because the prose is dense and difficult, it isn’t, but because it’s overwhelming and utterly absorbing. I haven’t read The People in the Trees but I bought it before I’d finished A Little Life as I want to see whether there’s any hint that she’d produce a work this significant afterwards.

  3. I’m quite intrigued by this novel, even more so now that I know Hanya is a female author. I’ve bumped it up on my wish list but will take your advice to read it when I have a bit of extra time.

  4. I’m quite intrigued by this novel, even more so now that I know Hanya is a female author. I’ve bumped it up on my wish list but will take your advice to read it when I have a bit of extra time.

  5. Arg, the woman thing is so annoying! “Women’s books.” I’m so tired of readers–or is it critics? publishers?–who dismiss works about women! And I can easily see how 4 women instead of men would turn into Sex and the City. BTW, if you haven’t read Sex and the City, it’s nothing like the show. It’s much more serious, believe it or not. Nice review!

    • I think it’s institutionalised sexism. It’s certainly not everyone but there’s a clear pattern of female writers being rewarded for writing about men. I have read Sex and the City and almost all of Bushnell’s other novels, she’s a great writer. Thanks!

  6. Arg, the woman thing is so annoying! “Women’s books.” I’m so tired of readers–or is it critics? publishers?–who dismiss works about women! And I can easily see how 4 women instead of men would turn into Sex and the City. BTW, if you haven’t read Sex and the City, it’s nothing like the show. It’s much more serious, believe it or not. Nice review!

    • I think it’s institutionalised sexism. It’s certainly not everyone but there’s a clear pattern of female writers being rewarded for writing about men. I have read Sex and the City and almost all of Bushnell’s other novels, she’s a great writer. Thanks!

  7. I completely agree with your review – I actually didn’t know the author was a woman when reading it, and had I been pushed to categorise I probably would have guessed gay man! And when I realised afterwards I was slightly shocked as there are barely any female characters in it whatsoever. It certainly doesn’t pass the Bechdel test! And I agree that it probably wouldn’t have received the praise it does if it was about women. Apparently Yanagihara has said that she is more interesting in writing about men than about women as “men are friends in very different ways than women are friends”. Which is perhaps a slightly sad viewpoint!

    Gender politics aside, this is a book that will stay with me for a very, very long time – but I am unsure whether I would recommend it to anyone purely because of how harrowing it is. I still haven’t quite got my head around everything that happens in it. But out of all the Booker longlist books I’ve read (I think I’m on 5/6 of the top of my head) I think this one deserves to win the most so far.

    • Thank you. I’m intrigued about her desire to write about men. I suspect there are as many types of friendships between men as there are between women.
      I think I’ve read five of the longlist and it’s certainly still at the top of my list. I do wonder if Marlon James might be up there too though.

      • I’m just finishing Chimes and Marlon James was next on my list – definitely so now you have just said that! I really respect your viewpoint as always end up liking the books you have, so more and more am influenced in my reading by your reviews – so thank you very much!

        • What a lovely comment, thank you. Glad you enjoy the books. I loved The Chimes. I’m not very far into the James but love what I’ve read and it comes highly recommended by friends I trust.

          • I only just realised on buying A Brief History that he also wrote The Book of Night Women which is one of the most incredible books I’ve read and which I would strongly recommend!

          • Excellent. I was about to write ‘I have it on my shelf’ but we’re in the middle of moving house so I have it in a box somewhere! I’ll definitely read it soon though, thanks.

  8. I completely agree with your review – I actually didn’t know the author was a woman when reading it, and had I been pushed to categorise I probably would have guessed gay man! And when I realised afterwards I was slightly shocked as there are barely any female characters in it whatsoever. It certainly doesn’t pass the Bechdel test! And I agree that it probably wouldn’t have received the praise it does if it was about women. Apparently Yanagihara has said that she is more interesting in writing about men than about women as “men are friends in very different ways than women are friends”. Which is perhaps a slightly sad viewpoint!

    Gender politics aside, this is a book that will stay with me for a very, very long time – but I am unsure whether I would recommend it to anyone purely because of how harrowing it is. I still haven’t quite got my head around everything that happens in it. But out of all the Booker longlist books I’ve read (I think I’m on 5/6 of the top of my head) I think this one deserves to win the most so far.

    • Thank you. I’m intrigued about her desire to write about men. I suspect there are as many types of friendships between men as there are between women.
      I think I’ve read five of the longlist and it’s certainly still at the top of my list. I do wonder if Marlon James might be up there too though.

      • I’m just finishing Chimes and Marlon James was next on my list – definitely so now you have just said that! I really respect your viewpoint as always end up liking the books you have, so more and more am influenced in my reading by your reviews – so thank you very much!

        • What a lovely comment, thank you. Glad you enjoy the books. I loved The Chimes. I’m not very far into the James but love what I’ve read and it comes highly recommended by friends I trust.

          • I only just realised on buying A Brief History that he also wrote The Book of Night Women which is one of the most incredible books I’ve read and which I would strongly recommend!

          • Excellent. I was about to write ‘I have it on my shelf’ but we’re in the middle of moving house so I have it in a box somewhere! I’ll definitely read it soon though, thanks.

  9. Pingback: A Little Life – Hanya Yanagihara | A Writer's Epic

  10. Pingback: A Little Life – Hanya Yanagihara | A Writer's Epic

  11. I have seen A Little Life flood my Twitter feed for some weeks now, and I had no idea what it was about, or whether it was even my cup of tea. For what you say here, I think I would definitely enjoy this book, and I’m particularly interested in the non-defyning ethnicity and sexuality of the characters. However, yet again, we have a woman writing about men, which is totally fine, but I keep wondering why… Food for thought, eh? 🙂

  12. I have seen A Little Life flood my Twitter feed for some weeks now, and I had no idea what it was about, or whether it was even my cup of tea. For what you say here, I think I would definitely enjoy this book, and I’m particularly interested in the non-defyning ethnicity and sexuality of the characters. However, yet again, we have a woman writing about men, which is totally fine, but I keep wondering why… Food for thought, eh? 🙂

  13. As you know I had a number of ‘issues’ with the book ….that have actuall grown after finishing it and reflecting on it . I also think the book is overly long ( by perhaps 200 pp !) ….having said that , I found it totally absorbing whilst reading it and it is a brave look at the trauma of surviving abuse . Enjoy the event …well annoyed I can’t make it !

      • There are a number of critical and mixed reviews about. Sarah Churchwell in the Guardian was probably the ‘biggest’ so far but plenty of critical bloggers and lots of criticism on my Twitter feed. Personally my take is this: of course a 720 page book is going to have issues (and in a book that length they will vary from person to person, Yanagihara said this evening her two editors (US and UK) disagreed on the big issues) but this book is brave, important and for a number of readers, life changing. I suspect people will be talking about it for years to come. And that overrides any critical niggles.

      • Thanks Naomi – will look for Sarah Churchwell’s article – even more intrigued by issues are exactly what she set out to do & UK & US editors differing. You saying its brave & important and one that’ll be talked about for years certainly confirms I need to read it. Thank you.

        • I’ll be blogging about the interview on Friday so hopefully that’ll make more sense as to the issues (although it will be a very spoiler filled piece).

    • Probably best you weren’t there, everything that annoyed you about the book were things she deliberately set out to do! I’ll have a full piece up on Friday about it.

  14. As you know I had a number of ‘issues’ with the book ….that have actuall grown after finishing it and reflecting on it . I also think the book is overly long ( by perhaps 200 pp !) ….having said that , I found it totally absorbing whilst reading it and it is a brave look at the trauma of surviving abuse . Enjoy the event …well annoyed I can’t make it !

      • There are a number of critical and mixed reviews about. Sarah Churchwell in the Guardian was probably the ‘biggest’ so far but plenty of critical bloggers and lots of criticism on my Twitter feed. Personally my take is this: of course a 720 page book is going to have issues (and in a book that length they will vary from person to person, Yanagihara said this evening her two editors (US and UK) disagreed on the big issues) but this book is brave, important and for a number of readers, life changing. I suspect people will be talking about it for years to come. And that overrides any critical niggles.

      • Thanks Naomi – will look for Sarah Churchwell’s article – even more intrigued by issues are exactly what she set out to do & UK & US editors differing. You saying its brave & important and one that’ll be talked about for years certainly confirms I need to read it. Thank you.

        • I’ll be blogging about the interview on Friday so hopefully that’ll make more sense as to the issues (although it will be a very spoiler filled piece).

    • Probably best you weren’t there, everything that annoyed you about the book were things she deliberately set out to do! I’ll have a full piece up on Friday about it.

  15. Pingback: #DiverseDecember: A Little Life | findingtimetowrite

  16. Pingback: #DiverseDecember: A Little Life | findingtimetowrite

  17. Pingback: The Bailey’s Women’s Prize for Fiction Longlist 2016 | The Writes of Woman

  18. Pingback: The Bailey’s Women’s Prize for Fiction Longlist 2016 | The Writes of Woman

Comments are closed.